Singapore Democrats

Home News Singapore Operation Spectrum open forum: a good start
Operation Spectrum open forum: a good start Print E-mail
Sunday, 28 June 2009

Singapore Democrats

After 22 years, we are beginning to see more public events that address the Internal Security Act (ISA) detentions in 1987.

 

In May a group of five activists came together to mark the 22nd anniversary of the Marxist arrests. Led by Seelan Palay, the group got together at Hong Lim Park and called for the for the abolishment of ISA. (See here and here.)

On Sunday afternoon, Martyn See organised discussion forum about the 22 arrests. The indoor event was supposed to have taken place last Saturday. However, about before that, the owner of the venue called Martyn to inform him that he had to cancel the booking to to an ongoing CID investigation (see here.)

Undeterred and despite further police harassment, Martyn sought out another venue and held the forum yesterday. Activists, bloggers, politicians, civil society actors and reporters turned up for the event.

Ex-detainee Michael Fernandez spoke about why he was detained by the Internal Security Department (ISD) in 1964 for nine years for his role in championing for workers rights back then.

Alex Au pointed out whilst Singaporeans were bombarded with the Marxist plot propaganda, that the other side of the story, has never quite been told. He urged the ex-detainees to write about their arrests and their experiences thereafter.

Former ISEAS senior fellow, Russell Heng wondered why the government had arrested these 22 young men and women when it flew against the face of logic. He was also unsure if civil society has evolved to become less afraid of the threat of the ISA being used on them.

SDP's Chee Siok Chin then spoke about the lack of public outrage when it was clear that the arrests were farcical. She spoke about the current JI detainees and how similar it is to the 1987 arrests in that there have been no questions asked about these non-transparent detentions. Ms Chee also spoke about the PAP's strategy of making sure that the people do not come together to challenge oppressive policies. She urged those in the audience to contact groups who are advocating for transparency and to work with them, including the Singapore Democrats.

John Tan encouraged the audience not to turn a blind eye to injustice and violations of human rights. Civil participation is badly needed in our society if we want to be a vibrant democracy. He honed in the point that Singaporeans must look out for each other and even those beyond our shores. In the final analysis, Mr Tan argued, the ISA must be abolished in order to prevent another Operation Spectrum in the future, and to remove the fear that grips Singaporeans when it comes to citizen participation.

The forum discussion was peppered with Martyn reading excerpts of torture from So That We May Dream Again, a compilation of brief essays of the 1987 arrests, To Catch a Tartar by Francis Seow and also an extract about Chia Thye Poh from Chee Soon Juan's book To Be Free.

Martyn ended the forum with the assurance that this will not be the last forum he will hold about the ISD's unlawful arrests of the 22 young people some 22 years ago.

Share this article:
Facebook Technorati Stumble It! Newsvine Reddit Del.icio.us Digg This!
Comments (5)
  • zah - Failure of Revisiting History Forum
    The low standard of the discourse, attendance and hence failure of the REVISITING HISTORY-Operation Spectrum - Breaking The Ice After 22 Years event yesterday is important to note.

    It captured the complain culture that sucks the time of civil society activists too much. These arrests as done in Op Spectrum and others over the decades post-death of Barisan Socialis were meant to “cut a chicken to frighten 10 monkeys” especially among the English Educated.

    No point keep complaining most of the detainees were social activists but not out to subvert the system. It was meant to be that way for maximum effect of raising the fear levels.

    Wallowing in self pity without offering any proactive strategies to combat the lost of our political and civil rights puts people off more and more from the political struggle against the PAP oppression. I do feel sitting there in the forum we really cannot afford such a misjudgement on the part of the organisers of the forum.
  • maxchew - Invite Director ISD to give the key-note address
    Martyn See should try to invite the current Dir ISD (a scholar high-flyer) to address the attendees in the next forum. He's likely to decline as he would not want to answer questions amongst other things. But we should have it on record that we did invite him to hear the ISD's side of the story. If they have convincing reasons for the arrest and detention of the 22 do-gooders, why not let us hear them now. Convince us the way your predecessor Mr Tjong Yik Ming and his deputy Mr Sim Poh Heng convinced HomeAffairs Minister Wong Kan Seng and the then PM LKY!
  • BryanT
    I wonder if such a forum would have been permitted many years back. The fact is that the forum went ahead with any overt action taken against organisers by authorities to purportedly induce fear in others. John Tan has gotten what he wants - "to remove the fear that grips Singaporeans when it comes to citizen participation".

    In that light, what Russel Heng said is also ironical. The fact that he attended and spoke up (bravely) contradicts his point that he is "unsure if civil society has evolved to become less afraid of the threat of the ISA being used on them". Is he not less afraid?

    As to Alex Au's request for the ex-detainees to write about their arrests. One wonders why that they have not spoken out after all this while (if that is indeed the case). If they were so upfront in standing up for their cause then, why not speak up now? Is that not tacit agreement that perhaps there is some truth in the official storyline.

    We should also ask Michael Fernandez whether if he repeated what he did in 1964 to champion workers' right, would he expect to be arrested again, under the current climate. I believe civic society has evolved partly because the government has allowed it to. If that is the case, we must give credit where credit is due, even if it is minuscule still. I believe this - if the opposition and civic organisations speak rationally and demand responsibly, the space for debate will be allowed to widen even if not at the pace desired.
  • quantum
    http://singaporerebel.blogspot.com/2009/07/police-retracts-licence-request-after.html

    Police retracts licence request after Minister queried
  • Simpang Bedok - Russell Heng
    Russell Heng could not even get his facts right. He called the 1987 detainees working class people.All the detainees had some form of tertiary education.2 or 3 were top students in their time. Certainly as young adults they were not working class at all. In any case white collar all of them. The forum was another example of idle time. Good for a laugh, I suppose. Nothing serious!
Please login or register to post your comments.
 

Latest Videos

Dr Chee Soon Juan's address at SDP's 30th Anniversary Dinner
by SingaporeDemocrats

You need a Flash Player enabled browser to view this YouTube video
youtube link
Share this article:
Facebook Technorati Stumble It! Newsvine Reddit Del.icio.us Digg This!
 
SDP's 30th Anniversary Dinner
by SingaporeDemocrats

You need a Flash Player enabled browser to view this YouTube video
youtube link
Share this article:
Facebook Technorati Stumble It! Newsvine Reddit Del.icio.us Digg This!
 


 

Awesome Words

To avoid making a mistake, say nothing, do nothing and be nothing.

Anonymous

Other languages

Banner
Banner
Banner

Act Now

More options
 
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
 

Ads

News feeds

Singapore Democrat News
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack