Singapore Democrats

Home News Asia Dr M: LKY has no respect for religion
Dr M: LKY has no respect for religion Print Email
Monday, 31 January 2011
Shazwan Mustafa Kamal
The Malaysia Insider


Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamed continued his attacks today against his political contemporary, Lee Kuan Yew, and accused him of disrespecting the religions and sensitivities of other races.

The former prime minister’s harsh remarks in a Mingguan Malaysia interview was a response to what the Singapore Minister Mentor said in a recently released book, “Kuan Yew: Hard Truths to Keep Singapore Going”.

Lee had urged Muslims in Singapore, who he said were socially “distinct and separate”, to “be less strict on Islamic observances” to aid integration and the city-state’s nation-building process.

"I am not surprised by his statement because to him (Lee) religion is not important. For him the end justifies the means, so if he wants racial integration in Singapore, he won’t let Islam stand in the way of his goals. He has no respect for religion and the sensitivities of other people," Dr Mahathir said.

In the interview with Mingguan Malaysia, the Umno-owned Utusan Malaysia weekend edition, Dr Mahathir rebuked Lee for suggesting that Islam was not a progressive religion, and that it stood in the way of the island nation’s developments.

"Islam in itself is progressive enough," Dr Mahathir said.

The acerbic politician claimed that the Malays in Singapore were constantly under siege from the ruling government, and had no choice but to compromise their Islamic beliefs.

"The Malays over there are actually afraid of the government . . . for instance, if they are served with food that is haram (non-halal) they have to accept it. Our culture here is that if pork were served to us we would not eat it . . . but in Singapore there is a fatwa that if (pork) was served to Muslims, they cannot complain about and (they) have to accept it.

"This is because they are afraid under such a government rule," said Dr Mahathir, who likened the current Singapore administration to Russia’s rule of Muslims in the past, whereby many Muslims became "communists" out of fear of the Russian government.

The former Umno president also appeared to blame Lee for Singapore’s separation from Malaysia.

He claimed that Lee, back in 1964, had "broken" an unofficial agreement set out by the late Tunku Abdul Rahman, whereby Lee’s party (The People’s Action Party) was supposed to limit its influence to only Singapore and not Peninsular Malaysia, or Sabah and Sarawak.

"But during the 1964 elections PAP tried to move here and give the impression that the Chinese were under threat by using slogans like Malaysian Malaysia, as though Malaysia only belonged to the Malays.

"This sentiment was propagated by Kuan Yew and Tunku saw this as something dangerous . . . which is why he decided to separate Singapore and give it its independence,” said Dr Mahathir.

The country’s fourth prime minister has been ramping up his attacks against Malaysia’s neighbouring country over recent weeks.

Last week he suggested that Malaysia was a more democratic country than Singapore, and argued that the island republic’s “disciplined” image was at the expense of the freedom of its citizens.

Dr Mahathir had said the reason why Malaysians were not as disciplined as Singaporeans was because Malaysia was more “democratic” and did not resort to extreme measures in governing the country.

He has also insisted that Singaporean Malays were being marginalised and denied their rights by the Singaporean government.

http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/malaysia/article/dr-m-kuan-yew-has-no-respect-for-religion/
Share this article:
Facebook Technorati Stumble It! Newsvine Reddit Del.icio.us Digg This!
Comments (3)
  • Tan Tai Wei
    What LKY had in mind could be "divisive" practices which Muslims need not be "strict" about because arguably not really required by Islam given a "progressive" interpretation. These examples might illustrate.

    Forced conversions surely have no religious value in any religion, and yet you can't marry a Muslim here and in Malaysia without converting to Islam. This is not only forced, but hypocritical as it's not for the love of Allah but using Him as means towards another end. And it is not necessarily an Islamic requirement. Someone I know married an Indonesian Muslim but he need not convert.

    I've heard of problems in offices, colleges and schools where Muslims asked for special rooms for prayers, or special tables to eat. Now, Islam says you can place your mat and pray anywhere provided you face the direction of Mecca, and that you eat "hallal" food. So, you don't have to be "strict" about having special rooms and tables. To be sure, where rooms are available and can be given without appearing to favour one religion at the expense of other religions and disadvantaging people in general, why not? But it should not be demanded, and fussed about. As to sitting with others whilst eating "hallal" food, this would be fulfilling both purity at eating, and also Islam's injunction to love other people and spread the love of Allah to them.
  • Tan Tai Wei
    One related example.

    Just as forced conversion has no religious value, so, too, forced retention of persons in the faith.

    In creation story shared by Muslims and Christians, God created man and woman with freewill. Adam and Eve could and did choose to disobey. Allah had that much respect for persons and their freedom.

    So it cannot be a tenet of Islam that whoever convert from Islam to another Faith, or to no Faith, are to be ostracised, with the implication that all others outside the Islamic fold are similarly disvalued. (Therefore a "divisive" practice.)
  • freedomT
    The truth will only be known when SDP and opposition parties become the elected government on why Dr Mahathir has been saying about this.
Please login or register to post your comments.
 

Announcements

Event re-scheduled to 2 June 2012 (Sat)!
More details

 

Latest Videos

Chee Soon Juan's speech at the Oslo Freedom Forum
You need a Flash Player enabled browser to view this YouTube video
youtube
link

Speeches at SDP's May Day Rally 2012
You need a Flash Player enabled browser to view this YouTube video
youtube link

GE2011 - One Year On
You need a Flash Player enabled browser to view this YouTube video
youtube Link

Highlight of SDP's May Day Rally 2012
You need a Flash Player enabled browser to view this YouTube video
youtube Link

Share this article:
Facebook Technorati Stumble It! Newsvine Reddit Del.icio.us Digg This!
 

Act Now

Please Donate
More options to donate
 

The SDP National Healthcare Plan

SDP Publictaions

Magazine Support SDP , buy our 30th Anniversary Magazine here


                        pdf link

minsal
pdf
link

 

Danny the Democracy Bear

Now available online here!

 
Banner
Banner

Awesome Words

Only a fool turns his back on what history can teach him.

Diderot
Banner

News feeds

Singapore Democrat News
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack